Should We Use the Defense Production Act to Force Companies to Manufacture Personal Protective Equipment?

Ted Cruz has come forward and placed pressure on President Trump to use The Defense Production Act to our collective advantage right now. He wants Trump to force companies to start mass-producing ventilators. While we can all understand the argument in favor of this, it is surprising to hear it coming from Ted Cruz, of all people.

Cruz looking to implement a wartime economy is surprising when you stop to consider the fact that he is typically aligned with smaller government. On the issue of ventilator manufacturing, he is willing to take a stand but there are efficiency questions that need to be answered first.

If Trump is giving these types of orders to the private sector, are we actually going to get more ventilators? Are they going to be able to manufacture them quickly? Unfortunately, we have very little reason to keep the faith. There is nothing that the federal government has done lately that will inspire any sort of confidence in their ability to handle a crisis.

How can we honestly believe that they are going to move to end this crisis in a faster manner that private interests will? Ted Cruz emerging as a voice of reason is not something that we saw coming. He’s one of the few members of Congress that seems willing to acknowledge the seriousness of the virus, instead of downplaying it at every turn.

If nothing is done, the nation is going to be facing a ventilator shortage. The public health threat that is currently taking place is not going to solve itself. Cruz makes a great point when he says that we need to be taking the right steps on the front end, so that we are not forced into a truly impossible situation on crisis’ back end.

The Defense Production Act is one of the best resources that we have in these types of scenarios. This law was put into place during the Korean War era. The federal government is given the power to impose certain orders on private industries when the nation is in need of crucial items.

If a leader is effective, the necessary equipment is produced in a more efficient manner because the orders are coming from a singular authority. For example, China was able to build a wide range of hospitals essentially overnight when they were in need of additional housing for their coronavirus patients.

The White House has yet to show that they can function in such a manner. They do not know exactly how many masks and ventilators are needed at various hospitals. It is hard to make the necessary decisions when there is no data to work with. If they knew more about the places that needed the most assistance, they would be able to streamline supply and demand far more easily.

In this situation, the White House comes across as more of a gelatinous mass with very little harmony. Does the left hand always know what the right hand is doing? It is hard to answer that question in the affirmative. Lots of companies are looking to step forward and help out but they cannot receive a straight answer from anyone who is connected to the Trump administration.

The confusion is widespread, keeping private industries from being able to assist. Corporate executives are facing a wide range of requests and several nations find themselves in need of various supplies. The White House has yet to even establish a priority list for deliveries. The states and cities that are currently getting hit the hardest do not know if they are going to be able to receive the assistance they require.

By avoiding The Defense Production Act, Trump is doing his best to avoid the personal responsibility for the shortages that are already taking place. Unless the government is willing to make purchasing guarantees, private industries are not going to crank up their production lines. The economy is in free fall and manufacturers cannot afford to make major investments without these assurances.

Governors have already pressed Trump on the issue. He claimed that they could purchase their own and ask for reimbursement later. This mentality creates a sizable amount of confusion and no one seems to know who is actually going to make things happen. This is obviously not ideal when the nation is in the midst of an unprecedented crisis.

We suspect that the White House will handle this in the same way that they have been: very slowly. Don’t be surprised when you see the mayors of major cities on television next week taking Trump to task when they do not have access to the proper medical equipment.


  1. Long time supporter, and thought I’d drop a comment.

    Your wordpress site is very sleek – hope you don’t mind me asking what
    theme you’re using? (and don’t mind if I steal it?

    I just launched my site –also built in wordpress like yours– but the theme slows (!)
    the site down quite a bit.

    In case you have a minute, you can find it by searching for “royal cbd” on Google (would appreciate any feedback) – it’s still in the works.

    Keep up the good work– and hope you all take care of yourself during the coronavirus

  2. I’m 70 and I realize that the country is dealing with 2 bad things, the COVID-19, and the economic problems it is creating.
    I understand we need to all we can to help. The future belongs to the youth. I for one would be willing to go to work and chance the virus in order to keep the economy moving. I am certain that most folks my age would agree.

  3. Whoever wrote this article must not be listening to the daily briefings. The administration is doing a great job of keeping the public informed just sounds like you want to criticize when you don’t have a clue what you are talking about

  4. This is a war against a deadly invisible opponent, a VIRUS , and every possible action should be taken to supply the people with the items needed to defeat the enemy, and those who are using this to make a obnoxious profits or refuse to cooperate and those who use emergency action bills in congress to advance NON-EMERGENCY items should be punished as “war criminals”.

  5. If the administration sees the necessity, then what else can reasonable people do? However, don’t you think the spirit of America is better reflected in a situation like we have now if companies and people voluntarily jump on board and together we handle this? We are a Constitutional Republic. For far too long our elected representatives have engaged in taking the power from we the people and scattering it around D.C. If this event simply continues and increases that, we’re headed for a totalitarian one party state.

  6. Roger, who’s fault is it that “one” party is trying to disregard the Constitution? It is the so-called leaders of that party who want us to adopt socialist tendency. Yes we are a Constitutional Republic and we can remain that way by supporting our President for re-election.

    • Yes / augment sounds good but I prefer to go with trump’s way of encouraging people and industry in the long run. Did you notice what’s going on in n.y. Were they are demanding / they allow o require people herded together which causes the problems.


  8. The Nation is undergoing a serious pandemic, and there is a desperate need for medical supplies and equipment. Obama allowed the Nation’s stockpile of emergency supplies and equipment to be ignored, thereby causing this emergency response capability. Under the current situation, we should do all we are able to do to take care of our citizens who are in possible loss of life status. If more medical supplies/equipment are needed to fulfill the shortages, then by all means we should use any and/or all of our resources, including companies/firms/corporations to produce what is needed.

  9. Hell yes companies that operate in the United States should be required to assist in this massive requirement for medical supplies/equipment. It isn’t just the Patriotic thing to do, but the morally thing to do as well.

  10. Hey! This is kind of off topic but I need some guidance from an established blog. Is it difficult to set up your own blog? I’m not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty fast. I’m thinking about setting up my own but I’m not sure where to start. Do you have any tips or suggestions? Thank you|

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.